Don't double-down on Af-Pak

What a mess! 20 or so Saudis destroyed the Twin Towers and the fight goes on and on. If 20 Italians blew up London Bridge what would be the correct response?--Yes, of course, find the culprits and bring them to justice-but no need to invade and occupy Italy. But, plainly, invasion and occupation of Muslim lands seems to be the plan de jure.

We have, now, a Christian vs. Islamic battle going on. We need to tack in another direction. Like, get out of there.

Obama says we got sidetracked by Iraq and now we're doing the real show--killings the locals (Pashtuns AKA Taliban) in Afghanistan and Pakistan. There's got to be a reason we're there-- yes, dampen down Islamic fervor but also we want the energy and it routes. This is Dick Cheney's wet dream--control energy supplies and energy routes...

President Obama’s stated rationale for sending more troops and providing additional aid to Pakistan/Afghanistan is that we're there to prevent Al Qaeda/Taliban from attacking the US. This rationale begins to wear thin after hearing it so many times over the years in regard to: Russia, China, Korea, Cuba, Vietnam, Nicaragua, San Salvador etc.

Moreover, if we’re afraid of a terrorist attack on US soil from Pakistan/Afghanistan, we need to also consider possible attacks from any number of teetering-on–the-brink countries: Haiti, Somalia, Moldova, Mexico, etc. In this globalized age a Bin Laden’s can operate from anywhere and short of going to war with the entire world, we need a smarter strategy than invading and occupying.

Strangely, there’s never a mention of energy (oil, gas) and Afghanistan in the same sentence. The country is strategically located atop major energy routes. In the past the Bush administration negotiated with the Taliban on delivery routes for these vital resources. Is this a current possibility?

I'm no expert but I can tell you the Obama plan of re- invading Pakistan/Afghanistan is DOA. Just ask the master of foreign armies dying in that country, Rudyard Kipling. The place is still part of the "Great Game"--countries near and far want a piece of the action--energy routes, geopolitical control. So India fights Pakistan (solve this one and the whole region will quiet down!), the Taliban/Pushtuns fight Russia, USA, Iran. The place needs a grand bargain--make it neutral like Switzerland, offer a little something to everyone.